FW: Shapeshifter Service Type Change Request


Wich, Daniel
 

Hi Jelle,

 

I have some feedback to think about on the ServiceType change, nothing blocking, probably an extension of the change or an addition to the specification (a new change):

 

“Because we introduce the ServiceType attribute to the FlexRequest message type I think it’s recommended to align on introducing a RejectionReason in the FlexRequestResponse message type that handles issues with the (contents of the) attribute.

It can be the case that a FlexRequest is sent with a ServiceType containing freeformat text like “Something completely random” that the AGR/CSP will receive.

You’d want to get a FlexRequestResponse messagetype back with the Result field set to “Rejected” and the RejectionReason set to “Unknown ServiceType <ServiceType>”:

Second scenario I can think of is that the optional field is added but the contents are empty; then you’d like to receive something in the line of “Optional field <fieldname> detected but its value is empty” or do we want to accept that by default we can add an optional attribute to messages but don’t fill in any value?

(Page 28 UFTP 1.01 specification)

This will save you time and effort when troubleshooting rejected transactions.

 

Apologies if this isn’t the right entry for the feedback; I wanted to give everyone the chance to read it before next weeks meeting.

 

Kind regards,

Daniel

 

Van: Steegh, Robert <Robert.Steegh@...>
Verzonden: dinsdag 15 februari 2022 09:10
Aan: Brouwer, Sietse <Sietse.Brouwer@...>; Griffioen, Nico <Nico.Griffioen@...>; Kupers, Martijn <martijn.kupers@...>; Meesters, Chris <Chris.Meesters@...>; Pourasghar Khomami, Dela <dela.pourasghar-khomami@...>; Schoorl, Mathijs <Mathijs.Schoorl@...>; Schulz, Erik <Erik.Schulz@...>; Stomp, Kuno <Kuno.Stomp@...>; Westerlaken, Olga <Olga.Westerlaken@...>; Wich, Daniel <daniel.wich@...>
Onderwerp: FW: Shapeshifter Service Type Change Request

 

Ter info de voorgestelde aanpassingen aan het UFTP protocol ter ondersteuning van BI-laterale (lange termijn) contracten.

 

@Daniel: Specs zijn conform wat ik vorige week heb afgesproken. Check jij nog even of het volgens jouw ook klopt.

 

Robert

 

Van: Edward Ross <edward.ross@...>
Verzonden: maandag 14 februari 2022 19:09
Aan: Jelle Wijnja <jelle.wijnja@...>; hugo@...; Aartse Tuijn, Jasper <Jasper.Aartse.Tuijn@...>; Heer, Hans de <Hans.deHeer@...>; Steegh, Robert <Robert.Steegh@...>
Onderwerp: Shapeshifter Service Type Change Request

 

Dear all,

 

Please find attached decision notes from our meeting about the Service Type on 10th Feb.

 

I’ve also created the issue and pull request ready for review.

 

https://github.com/shapeshifter/shapeshifter-specification/issues/3

 

Best regards,

 

Ed.

 

--

 

Edward Ross

Technical Director

 

Delivering smart energy now…

 

 

Gridimp Limited

Address: Wells Enterprise Centre, Cathedral Avenue, Wells, Somerset, BA5 1JJ

Telephone: 01749 372198 

Website: www.gridimp.com

 

The information in this email is confidential and solely for the use of the intended recipient(s). If you receive this email in error, please notify the sender and delete the email from your system immediately. In such circumstances, you must not make any use of the email or its contents.

Views expressed by an individual in this email do not necessarily reflect the views of gridIMP Ltd.

 

Computer viruses may be transmitted by email. gridIMP Ltd accepts no liability for any damage caused by any virus transmitted by this email. E-mail transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. It is possible that information may be intercepted, corrupted, lost, destroyed, arrive late or incomplete, or contain viruses. The sender does not accept liability for any errors or omissions in the contents of this message, which arise as a result of e-mail transmission.

gridIMP Ltd.


Registered office: Bishopbrook House, Cathedral Avenue, Wells, Somerset, BS5 1FD . Registered in England.
Registered number: 7832551 .